Saturday, April 25, 2009

RPS Essay

This is my submission for the contest at Rock Paper Shotgun.

I think that the best science fiction film was Star Wars Episode 2: Attack of the Clones. I wanted to pick a Star Wars film, as I believe the series is the most influential sci-fi series in changing film and fiction in general. However, I feel that the original films are not indicative of the rich and deep political climate that is present throughout George Lucas' Star Wars universe. Episodes 4-6 are very classic examples of good versus evil, and while they are rife with interesting and shocking plot twists, they do not move us to change our outlooks on life or what is right and wrong.

Episode 2 is by far the best at making us think about the actions of each of the characters in the movie and ask ourselves whether they are right or wrong. Each of the main characters has their own particular moral compass, and this causes them to make many interesting choices throughout the film. Each time this happens, we are presented with a delightful dilemma - was what he or she did the right choice?

For our first example, we can take Obi-Wan. He's a pretty forthright, straightforward good guy. When we see him interact with Anakin in the early scenes, he is often stern with Anakin, chastising him. To some degree, Obi-Wan even belittles Anakin, in moments such as when he is questioning Anakin for why he would use Padme as bait to lure out the assassin. Are all of his decisions right in the movie? If everything had gone as he had wished, would Jango have been captured, or was the combination of Anakin and Padme's recklessness required in order to find Zam Wessel and later, Jango Fett?

Obi-Wan's caution is seen often in The Phantom Menace as being the voice of reason, but in Attack of the Clones his caution would have left him to forego opportunities that other characters, such as Padme or Anakin would push the story into exploring.

Anakin is the character that defines the moral ambiguity of the trilogy, though. He battles constantly with things like his love for Padme and his mother, things that the Jedi code discourage. These feelings get him into trouble and contribute to his eventual fall, but his expressions are all too human. While we frown at the way he murders the Tusken Raiders in vengeance, we also understand his fury at the loss of a loved one.

When we watch Episode 2, each of us has a different view of Anakin. Maybe we see his instability and arrogance as his defining traits, and frown on him because of that. Some of us might see his passion as a strength, rather than a weakness, though. Compared to the other Jedi, Anakin is much more 'human' and expresses emotions that we ourselves are likely to feel. The murder of his mother driving him to vengeance is something many people can relate with. I think that it is too easy to look at Anakin and condemn his feelings when he really is more like us than characters such as Obi-Wan or Yoda.

I can't talk about Anakin without mentioning Padme, though. She's every bit as reckless as he is, and her recklessness is almost always seen as a good thing throughout the movie. She is motivated to do the right thing at any cost, even if it puts her or others in danger. Even her arrival at Coruscant at the start of the movie is a decision fraught with peril. Numerous characters express concern that she should not have come. The major difference is that Anakin makes 'wrong' choices that end up getting people in trouble, while Padme makes choices that generally help the good guys out. However, it's important to note that the intent of these two characters is usually the same.

Although he had a pretty minor role in the movie, the morality of Chancellor Palpatine should also be addressed. In The Phantom Menace we see that the Republic is a slow, ponderous political beast with no real power, and that there is need for change. Palpatine, as the center of this change to a more stable system of government, is not truly a bad guy. Although we know that he becomes the "evil" Emperor later, and that he is the Dark Lord of the Sith, I think labels like "Dark Lord" serve to mask the unity he is attempting to bring to the galaxy.

In Attack of the Clones, Palpatine makes his second step towards gaining control of the Republic by getting emergency executive power. He is also never clearly portrayed as both the Chancellor and Darth Sidious at the same time. If the viewer had never seen the prequels, he or she might even be fooled into thinking that they were not the same person. Palpatine is almost always shown as impeccably nice to everyone, and only Obi-Wan even speaks ill of him during the movie (in a line that mentions him as being just like all other politicians).

But the blurred moral lines are not the only things that make Episode 2 excellent. Attack of the Clones also has excellent pacing, and covers a lot of key events in sequence that makes sense and is easy to follow.

When I rewatched the movie in order to better elaborate on the morality points that would be the focus of my essay, I noticed a lot of excellent plot flow. The chase scene with the shapeshifter Zam Wessel was particularly interesting because although it had a lot of twists in the chase (Obi-Wan getting blasted off the droid, Anakin jumping off his speeder to land on Zam's, and the final 'showdown' in the bar) they do an excellent job of making the viewer feel like all these crazy occurrences are plausible and could reasonably happen together.

If summarized, the events of Episode 2 seem ridiculous. Why does Anakin go from Naboo to Tattoine to Geonosis... with Padme in tow? If one were to explain these things to anyone else, these events would sound absolutely crazy. But when actually watched, these events make total sense. The actors do a surprisingly good job of justifying where they are going and what they are going to do there. Each plot twist in the movie feels right. When we are watching, we don't ask ourselves, "How is Obi-Wan on Kamino?" When I thought about the movie before watching it, I couldn't remember how Obi-Wan got there (it seemed like such a big logic leap). But when watching it, it made total sense.

Another thing the plot does well is handle many characters in different places. In many television shows and movies we get confused about who is doing what, and where. Obi-Wan is headed after Jango to Geonosis, Anakin is on Tattoine, and so on. The information about the characters is presented in an easily digestable and memorable way so there's never any confusion. This is a pretty impressive feat and most movies that do this screw it up.

Lastly, the movie does a great job of playing homage to the movies that came before. The Lars family, little riffs of the Imperial March here and there, and lines like "Anakin, someday you'll be the death of me," serve to really bring the old memories back. I do think that knowledge of the old movies does detract a bit, since we have certain expectations in this movie because of them. However, for those of us who did see Episodes 4-6 many times before seeing Episodes 1 and 2 for the first time, the homages were a nice touch.

I feel that Attack of the Clones is highly underestimated as a film. I agree with many of the criticisms such as weak acting (especially by Hayden Christensen) and poor scriptwriting, but the actors deliver a compelling tale that keeps you entertained from start to finish. It also lets us look at real life ethical dilemmas instead of a clear-cut battle versus good and evil.

I hope that you enjoyed reading this essay. It took me quite a while to write, and required rewatching of Attack of the Clones and a few trips to Wookiepedia.

Thanks for reading. Hopefully I've motivated you to take a look at what is really a great film.

Thursday, April 23, 2009

Pride and Glory

Okay, so I suck and haven't written in a couple days. I'm sorry, really.

Today I'm going to talk about the difference between pride (bad) and self-confidence (good!). I'm also going to talk about how to help with self-confidence, but it's something you'll have to find for yourself.

One of the things that I harp on a lot in this blog indirectly is pride. I don't outright say that pride is a bad thing, but virtually everything I get upset about, such as elitism or exclusive community values is a direct result of pride. Today I'm going for the jugular.

Pride is a state of mind that most nerds fall into. I'd suggest that it's a huge ratio, like over 90% huge. When I was at Kumoricon last year, pretty much everyone I met exhibited pride. When I was in the military (not nerds, but worth analyzing), virtually everyone fell into this state of mind.

Pride is the feeling where you need accomplishments, particularly those that compare you to other people or that require other people for validation. Pride is what changes a philosophy like playing to improve into the aggressive, heartless "playing to win." Pride is what takes us and turns us into hostile beings. When we are prideful we treat attacks on our beliefs as attacks on ourself.

Pride is so bad that in the right amounts it can create massive amounts of nationalism and foster beliefs like the Crusades or the Holocaust. Pride leads to belief without testing - the idea that one can believe something "just because" without any real evidence. Pride makes us think that Horde players are better than Alliance players, or that ganking people on PvP servers (or in EVE) is okay because the game allows it.

What's worse really, is that pride is extremely hard to get rid of. I use this in bold because it I cannot emphasize it enough. I blame Dale Carnegie (who wrote How to Make Friends and Influence People) for getting me out of that mindset, along with certain key individuals in my life who pushed me along the right path. I would have never got rid of pride on my own.

There's really no right way for a nerd to escape the cycle without help. You'll need backup, and that backup most likely isn't going to come from the people you hang out with now. Most of your online friends you keep are going to drag you down. Most isn't even the best choice of words, but there are people you likely associate with who are keeping you in that state of mind.

The first thing I'd suggest is to set goals for yourself. I write a lot of articles about good mindsets to have, so point yourself in one of those directions. If you're not a gamer nerd, a pro writer, or some other nerdy person, you'll have to think of something that will point you in the direction of self-advancement. I 'leveled up' by wanting to be better at marketing, which naturally meant I wanted to understand people better.

The goals you set for yourself need to put you on the course of self-betterment, preferably for its own sake. Being the best player in the world at Street Fighter is not a good goal. It requires other people to validate whether or not you are. A better example might be to understand mindgames better, or to advance yourself in some other independent way.

But, beyond that is the belief that you don't need to be better than others to be valued. Alternatively, you might need to lose the belief that you need other people for validation. I'm not going to say "you should quit raiding" or "you should quit playing to win." Maybe your goal can be mutual respect (something I talked about) or some other worthy goal.

Next on the list of things I need to unfortunately tell you is that you are gonna have to get some new people to hang with. I think you saw this coming. If we want to get some sort of value in our hearts, we need to reduce the amount of time we spend with people who don't have these values. It's pretty obvious. If you're in a guild full of griefers, it's definitely time to get a new guild. If you're in a guild with a couple of problem people who cause lots of drama, you should try to reduce the amount of time you spend around those people. If you can, you should try to get them to change too, or barring that, maybe get them kicked from your guild (diplomatically, don't do anything underhanded!).

If the environment you're in is not conductive to you losing your pride, sadly you may have to quit your scene. I've seen people do this and it sucks, but sometimes you have to. I will not name any communities like this, but most MMORPG communities are big enough that you can get a 'fresh start' away from whoever was dragging you down without actually quitting. Most of the time, you won't even need to migrate servers or anything like that. But if you play a small competitive community where everyone drags each other down, it's time to go somewhere else.

Don't let jerks get in the way of your own personal self-fullfillment. Pride is a very hard thing to overcome. It's not something you do overnight. The first step is knowing that you are prideful, and the next step is wanting to change.

After that, it's all you, baby. Don't let us down!

Monday, April 20, 2009

Because there's no such thing as Internet Ninjas

Piracy on the internet is really rampant. I'm sure everyone is saying 'no, really?' but the rampant growth of internet piracy is important for today's topic.

I'm not going to talk about something boring like whether software piracy is a moral thing or not. I'm sure you have your own views on it. I'm pretty sure that if you guessed, you could figure mine out too.

What I am going to talk about is the impact of piracy on content providers.

The bottom line on content such as music or literature or software is that someone has to pay for it to get produced. It costs money to put CDs or books on the shelves, and it takes time to write books or make music. If they don't make a return on that time and money, they come out at a loss. So if we don't buy their stuff, they lose money, right?

This is seemingly not actually the case for many content providers though. Blame Society Productions has nearly all of their content available for free, either on their website or on youtube. It's pretty hard to pirate it when it is already free! However, Blame Society also sells DVDs and merchandise, and they make fairly good money even though the DVDs contain material you can already get on the internet for free without needing to pirate.

Other small-time content providers are also following this trend - all of their music, videos, or whatever can be seen online for free. They sell CDs and MP3s of their stuff and they still make enough money to live off of, and continue making music. Many of them do exceptionally well using this model.

Contrast this with Adobe Photoshop. PS is a very detailed and expensive program, but the development time for PS is laudable compared to the development time for most video games. Still, PS costs way too much money - far out of the reach of most internet artists. Although there are cheaper alternatives, PS is frequently pirated because the price is so out of reach for normal people that it's clear Adobe does not actually care about their product being pirated.

From my observations, I can see that the main people who are 'hurt' by piracy are bloated corporations who abused the existing marketing system and are too invested in the current marketing system to change. Big name bands have a lot to be hurt by piracy, because they already have all the publicity they need (who hasn't heard of Metallica?) and any money lost dips into their ability to live completely extravagant lifestyles.

We may lose a lot from big name companies not being able to make products, though. For instance, if movie companies could not put millions of dollars into movie production and make money, the overall quality of product may drop. Obviously this means nothing for the music industry or for books, but games and movies could drop in quality if we don't pay for their products.

Somehow, I don't see that happening though. The console gaming market is going very strong, and even PC game sales are steadily rising even in our garbage economy. Movies are also having strong increases in profit so I doubt that movie quality is going to drop anytime soon.

I think it's worth noting that a lot of content providers that aren't free, like gootecks, advocates free sharing of his content if you buy it. He's just looking to get by and he wants his information to be heard. I think, again, that is pretty awesome.

I don't think piracy or the internet are going to ruin the economy in any way. I do think it will continue to do damage to big music artists, but really, that market is so lacking in real talent right now that it deserves to be flipped. And honestly, there is not a lot we can do about it either way.

Again, this is nothing about the morality of piracy. You can draw your own conclusions on that.

Sunday, April 19, 2009

Winning Isn't Everything

I had every intent of writing 2 articles to make up for not writing one on Friday, but I was stumped for a topic. Fortunately, someone awesome decided to give me an idea for a preachy article.

This article is about fairness and "playing to win." Playing to win is a concept coined by David Sirlin, lead designer for Street Fighter HD and the author of the gaming blog sirlin.net In a nutshell, playing to win is having the mindset that a person should do anything it takes to achieve victory. All avenues to victory should be explored, and the concept of what is honorable should be condemned.

I agree with this view. I would not write a real article about it though if I did not have some sort of unique statement on it. It is not my intention to regurgitate his material; it's present on his website.

Playing to win is probably a bad idea for most people. In fact, I feel that the idea of playing to win is sort of a flawed view. I think that on many levels it is not a good idea. Only in one circumstance is it worth following - within the realms of tournament, league, or other ranked play. In these scenarios you should do everything you can to win, within the rules of the game. I don't think that disconnecting to avoid losses is a winning move, so perhaps I should restrict ranked play even further to say, ranked play that actually matters (eg. not XBL ranked matches or something).

The crux of my argument isn't what most people expect when they hear I dislike the playing to win mentality. I think that 'unfair' tactics should be used, because they're probably not unfair. I think that concession should not be given to a weaker opponent, such as a handicap or letting them get up without being harassed or whatever.

I dislike playing to win because it creates awful, egocentric player attitudes. If you adopt a 'win at all costs' mentality, you may win the games at hand, but you lose out on much more. You lose out on potential friends who may be offended by how you play. You most likely also lose out on good competition because if you pummel your opponents mercilessly, they may never get a chance to figure out how to beat you. Playing to win teaches people disrespect. It teaches people how to treat others poorly and how to look down on people who do not follow your ideals. This is a poor philosophy.

Instead, I believe in a philosophy of playing to learn, or playing to improve. In actuality, Sirlin and many pro SF players believe in this philosophy too. However, many people who read about playing to win miss the point, that the goal of playing to win is to shed the restrictions that hold us back so we can improve. It is not the actual victory that is the important thing. However, Sirlin and many of his friends were brought up in a world where there were numerous people who criticized them for their excellent play, and they saw themselves as clearly better. Such an idea as playing to win was very natural for them to create for themselves.

But this is 2008, not 1992. Playing to win is shouted over the internet as a phrase used to discriminate against "scrubs." This mentality is not something I can abide by.

Playing to learn is about improvement. Improvement at any cost, even winning or honor. No expense should be spared to get better. Instead of trying our best to defeat the enemy we're now trying our best to exceed our previous limits. If we can do this, winning is natural, because we're getting better and better.

Playing to learn is also about sharing and helping your other players get better too. Why would we care about other players? Even the most selfish player can agree with this - if you play better competition, you get better, period. This is absolutely undisputable.

Once upon a time I played Guilty Gear. I was decent at it. I played /slash and #reload, for reference. I played Ky in both games. Relative to the people near me, I was not as skilled, but I could compete. But one day they went to Evolution and suddenly I was far, far weaker than them. Then I played against them for a while and my skill level jumped dramatically higher in only a few weeks. Then I quit GG, mostly because my fingers were not skillful enough to keep up with my expectations for myself.

Helping people get to your skill level also helps you gain an understanding of overall play. If you see how other players develop and their tendencies and habits, you can adapt some of these things into your game plan. For instance, I am generally a 'safe' defensive player in fighting games. I like a relaxed, slow-paced game with few twists and thus, my play style is very boring. Many of my friends run the full range between overly cautious (more than me) and very aggressive and risky. Helping them improve by teaching them little nuances of play has also let me see how their playstyles work. In particular, the high risk players have taught me quite a bit about how to play a little edgier game and press advantage more. At the same time, my 'textbook' type play helps them improve their defense game too.

As a side note, I discovered 'The Book of Nothing' because of collaboration with a friend playing Street Fighter 4. I noticed that there were times when both of us would do really dumb things, like jump at each other at the exact same times. I looked a little deeper to find little habits embedded in each of us. I told myself, "hey, maybe it's because doing things at the first opportunity might not always be smart" and I explained it to my friend. That day, we practiced hard to not do things at the right time, and instead do them later, earlier, not at all, and so on. We got a lot better that day! I feel sort of lame explaining that I learned all of that playing SF4, like I should have known it sooner.

Back on topic, playing to learn means throwing away all concept of victory sometimes because when you are playing casually, either on console or at the arcade, you want to mess around. I'll use a more specific example to illustrate this more clearly.

In Soul Calibur, being knocked down is really bad for you. It's highly dangerous to get knocked down because you are totally at your opponent's mercy. They can hit you on the ground, they can hit you while you're getting up and they get way more choices about what to do than in a 2D fighter. Your opponent has tons of tempo advantage and your options are very few.

In this knocked down situation you should experiment with any and all options you have because you may find that you have some new option you didn't know about. For instance, as soon as you start rising, you can start inputting attacks. Your attacks have almost zero chance of beating your opponent's, because they get to start their attack very early. But you could do a move with some sort of evasion or parry to try and deflect their attack. If they guess a certain way, attacking becomes actually a viable option instead of just having to guess blocking high or low, or staying on the ground. However, the specific options available to you need testing. In a lot of cases your character might not have any good attacks to use. Some characters might have several!

Another situation is with 'cheap' moves. Playing to win is very clear on this issue. Abuse the cheap moves! But playing to learn is not so clear. If it is clear your opponent can't beat a particular move or series of moves, the best option you have is to teach them how to beat it. If you don't know, you should try to figure out a way to beat that move. For instance, if your friend dies every time to a proxy gateway rush, you should teach him how to defeat it. Instead of playing lots of 3-minute games where your friend is frustrated, you beat him once then talk it over. "How do you beat that?" Once you explain how to defeat your strategy, then you're naturally forced into developing new counter strategies. And maybe the same can be said in reverse, if your opponent figures out something tricky, he will be more apt to show you how to beat it if you taught him how to beat your proxy gateway rush.

Playing to learn is a journey of cooperation. If the people around you grow, so will you.

I am not the only person to hold these philosophies. Ryan Gutierrez, better known on the internet as gootecks, has a program in his local area that he calls "Scrubs to Winners' Clubs." His friends take players that suck at Street Fighter, and give them training time, teach them basics, and help them become winners. Ryan and his crew are doing awesome work for the SF community, and I applaud their efforts. I know that they don't quite understand all the concepts of 'playing to learn' the same way I do (good players aren't as good at explaining things, fortunately I am not very good!), but they do know that building the community will help everyone get better. You can check his stuff out at gootecks.com, he has a ton of podcasts and a blog too.

I could explain a lot of anecdotes about how playing to learn has improved my skills at various games, even if the 'scrubs' I taught never really made it to the winners' clubs. But as I understand more about how people learn things, I'll get better at teaching and my competition will get better at teaching me new things too.

Unfortunately, I'm stuck being only good at Soul Calibur, lol.

Saturday, April 18, 2009

Complex vs. Simple in Action

Sorry for not writing last night, I'll try to make it up today though.

In an unusual turn of events, I'm going to talk about related topics back-to-back. In this case, I'm going to talk about the same thing! Simple versus Complex, in living color.

Devil May Cry 4 was my favorite game of 2008 as I mentioned before. There were lots of good games that year, but DMC4 was the winner for me. The DMC series is a decent example of emergent design, especially the first game. The heroes in DMC have a wide variety of moves and attacks. Many of these moves have hidden properties or things to exploit. In DMC1 for instance, the grenade launcher was mostly cancellable into other moves. This property let it be exploited both as a devil meter building tool and a damage tool, since you could fire the grenade launcher for almost no risk. In DMC3 you could do similar things using the fast weapon switch to cancel normal attacks into other normal attacks.

DMC4 shook things up a little bit by introducing Nero. DMC3's version of Dante had numerous different moves and abilities and was a little bit daunting to play. Nero was a big break from this. He has far fewer moves than DMC3's Dante and the moves he does have are for the most part easier to execute. He has small amounts of complexity, but most of the complexity in Nero's game comes from the emergent nature of his various 'special' abilities. This complexity is deeply hidden in Nero's design - a novice player can feel very strong without ever needing to explore this complexity, while an advanced player will quickly find it and have new things to learn.

Nero's core design is pretty simple. He has sword moves, a grab attack, and jumping moves. He also has a gun that can be charged up for bonus effects. His sword moves are the most complex thing about him - he has like several dozen different sword attacks, but you only need about ten or so to play him and have fun. The basic sword moves are very easy to do and intuitive (towards and sword, away and sword, jumping towards and sword...) which makes it much easier to learn those moves. There are only 3 grab moves (lock on and grab, no lock and grab, hold grab) but the no lock grab is very visually impressive and has a unique animation depending on which enemy you grab. It's the one novice players use most often anyway. The lock on grab is really nice too because it lets Nero get close to his enemy with less trouble, which means more time in the action (and even if a novice never really learns to use it well, there are other moves to get close too).

The main character of the previous games, Dante, is also playable. He is not a simple character at all. He feels very weak and shallow until you are adept at using the many different style moves he has. Novice players will tend to stick with one style, but you are hugely penalized for doing this. The game expects Dante to switch between his styles frequently to adapt to different scenarios, because his powers are not as versatile as Nero's charged shot/sword and Nero's grabs. This means Dante must switch between styles to deal damage and styles to defend. This type of gameplay is really unituitive to a novice. Even though Dante has some very overpowered things that he can do with rapid stance changing, these things are not simple and novice players will never really use them.

What is the point of this example? Well, game critics said DMC4 was a great game overall. They were skeptical about Nero at first, but he turned out to be more fun than Dante. These feelings were pretty much universal in the gaming media. Game Informer said something reminiscent of "Dante feels outdated" (not an exact quote) and that Nero felt a lot stronger. When I first read these things, I thought the GI reviewers were retarded. I don't actually think Dante is less powerful than Nero - he has a glitchy power attack that does even more damage than Nero's grabs, and he is extremely mobile and often invulnerable during his moves. But game reviewers were right - in the hands of beginners, Nero is definitely stronger and easier to use. Furthermore, Nero is fairly deep at the pro level, but all of his complexity is hidden and unneeded to actually play him as a beginner. Dante, on the other hand, has all of his complexity up front where you have to use it in order to play at all.

Before I go, I'll put a few things out there: The top fighting game in terms of tournament attendance was, for a long time, Super Smash Brothers Brawl. Every time I see a Brawl tournament it has over 100 people attending. The second most popular tournaments I see are Soul Calibur tournaments with full 64-man brackets. Street Fighter 4 (touted as being more simple than 3s or CvS2) gets similar numbers to SC. Guilty Gear (one of the hardest fighting games to play) gets very small numbers, typically a dozen or so.

SC and Brawl especially are super simple to learn the basics for. When I ask noobs what their favorite fighting game is, it's almost always one of those two games. Gameplay depth or balance aside, the simpler games are more popular and easier for people to get into.

I think complex fighting games are a dying breed. SF4 is pretty complex, but I think it sold mostly on brand recognition.

Simple is better! Really!

Friday, April 17, 2009

Simple sugars and complex carbohydrates

I AM BACK and I have internet now. So mostly daily updates again! Most likely, I won't be updating on Sundays, but I should be writing something pretty much every other day!

I've been reading many things on GMing, but nothing to do a good article on yet. So stay tuned for that.

I also have some things to say about interacting with people but I have been way too preachy lately. I feel like if I preach too much, I'll sound like a religious zealot or something. Maybe I already do?

So, today I'm going to talk about simple things. Simple things are good. Complexity is not so good.

Did I just say that?

Complexity is not actually a good thing. Let's say we have a MMORPG system where it is a pretty big opportunity cost to change your build. Let's further say that this system is highly complex and has many different possible choices for your build. A good number to suggest is thousands. I realize that many complex games these days have millions of possible builds, so thousands is actually sort of less complex.

In any game where there are numerous different build options, there are bound to be several best options, and that number is often a tiny fraction of the thousands or millions of possible options. If you chose a poor option, either because you were trying something you thought might be good or because you just liked the cosmetics of the option you chose, you may be stuck with that option or at least be forced to spend in-game money or resources to change it. This is a frustrating and bad outcome.

As an example of an 'almost balanced' complex system, let's look at the fighting game Arcana Heart. The original Arcana Heart has 11 different playable characters, and 11 different magic types. Each character can use all 11 magic types, but you can only pick one magic when you go into a battle. This gives us 121 different options, which is a lot. It is not thousands, but it is a lot - enough that our brains cannot quantify easily all 121 choices.

Some characters are strictly better with certain magics. The plant magic, for instance, only works with a certain few characters because it gives them some interesting mixups. Other characters can't really use the plant magic very well. Some characters benefit a lot from the wind magic for escape. Some characters get some crazy combos with time or fire magic. If you pick a sub-optimal choice of magic for your character, you will be at a fairly significant disadvantage. The characters themselves are reasonably balanced with each other, and the magics are for the most part very balanced. But because each character and magic interact differently, some choices are intrinsically bad.

Because there are only 121 choices, probably around half the choices are at least somewhat viable but even a 50% batting average is kind of bad. Considering there are probably only 2-3 good magics per character gives us around 30 or less high level options in a game with 121. What if Arcana Heart was an MMO, and you were locked into your choice of character and Arcana at the start of the game? People that chose Kamui/Dieu Mort would be out of luck.

Notably, City of Heroes uses a game system similar to this. There is no 'fix' for bad powerset selections, except to make a new character. Most other MMORPGs use some form of respecialization - you can't pick a new class, but the classes are more or less balanced around the 'top' builds, and that is a lot easier to balance than trying to balance every possible build selection.

So the reason why complexity by itself is bad is because it leads to bad choices. In a game like Street Fighter for instance, you can only choose one character from a very small list. Typically, these characters are balanced against each other for competitive play, so if you play Vega or Fuerte in SF4 (some of the worst) you have a pretty good chance if you understand your weaknesses. In a more complex game like Marvel vs. Capcom 2, picking a bad team is pretty much giving the match away (unless your opponent does too), even if you are significantly more skilled than your opponent.

The other reason why complexity is a bad thing is because complex systems are harder to learn. This can be a good thing, because learning is fun. However, if learning is too hard, we give up. Take WoW for instance - it has a very complex talent tree system and a very large list of equipment to wear. However, we don't really need to learn all of that right away, and by the time we realize our talent build sucks, we probably have enough gold to fix it a few times. Also, if our build sucks, the base class is still fairly good all on its own.

By comparison, take a look at Arcana Heart again. AH is a complex game all on its own. When we have to select a character and magic though, we probably have no idea what we're doing at first. Even worse is that it takes typically a lot of playing the game before we even understand what things like the plant or poison arcana are even good for. My circle of friends would not have even thought the dark arcana (probably the most flexible in the game) was good unless I had shown them how to use it properly.

So when we suggest that complexity is good, what do we actually mean?

Obviously complexity is not entirely bad. I really like complex systems (I play Guild Wars, lol) and think that dissecting complex systems is fun. What we're really looking for in complex systems is 'depth.'

Depth is a property of games that occurs when there are a large variety of interesting things to do in that game. If the game uses its system to create interesting and meaningful challenges for us to overcome, we tend to enjoy these challenges more than things that are 'just hard.'

A good example of depth is StarCraft, although I bet you guys never saw that coming. SC has only three races and a few core mechanics, but those mechanics interact deeply with each other in the form of numerous units and buildings that were meticulously balanced over a number of years. Even though SC has a lot of bugs/undocumented features in it, these bugs actually enhance gameplay at the high level and have been left in. SC has so many different types of interaction that it is pretty much impossible to memorize them all. Players such as Boxer, who are not as technically skilled as some of the younger prodigies today, still perform amazingly well because they are flexible and adaptive to many unusual interactions that occur in the match.

SC is a good example of how to use complexity to achieve depth. SC is very complex. It has a number of core mechanics, but these mechanics are put to use in dozens of different units. Each unit has a different purpose, and there is a lot of strangeness into how they interact. This strangeness is good and leads to many deep and interesting strategies.

A good game that is not very complex, but is pretty deep is checkers. Checkers has been solved by computers, but playing a game of checkers against a human usually leads to a lot of interesting plays with both players thinking very long on which move to make. Checkers only has a very small number of moves with only 2 different types of piece. However, it is very deep.

The reason for this depth is because of 'emergent gameplay' or the idea that certain mechanics working together cause an end result that is "greater than the sum of its parts."

However, I do not have a lot of time to write about this concept, so you are left with why we should not make things we do or say overly complex.

Until next time!

Sunday, April 12, 2009

Timing and Singing the Blues

Back from Sakura-con, I'm ready to write some more. I still don't have net at my house, though, so I am stealing my parents' internet.

I actually don't really have something I want to talk about right now, but interestingly enough I have a continuation of a topic about competition I'd like to revisit.

Before, we talked about space control. Controlling space is sort of the basics of any game and without threatening the enemy, we can't win the game. But tempo is almost as important, because controlling time keeps our enemy from fighting back, and knowing the times when he can counter and when he can not.

Some games are more about time than others. StarCraft is sort of limited in tempo because a player can do many many things simultaneously. There is still the issue of controlling the flow of the match, but it is usually through resource control or space control, which are still very cool things. Chess is a game largely about space control too, but tempo can be very important since sometimes you are threatened so much that you can't really attack without hurting yourself, and that lets your opponent attack more.

The games that are most about tempo are games where making one action precludes you from doing another, and actions take varying lengths of time. Even more about tempo is games with knockdowns or other ways to put your opponent at lots of time disadvantage. And lastly, mobility hurts tempo somewhat - the more a game allows you to escape and reset a situation, the worse controlling time is.

Remember when I talked about doing nothing? That is a lot of the basis of tempo. As soon as you make a choice to do something, you put yourself at some form of time disadvantage. If you attack, you must wait for that attack to end before you can defend yourself. If you choose to move around with some kind of dash or jump, you are committed to doing that jump or dash until it ends. Not all games have that kind of movement, but most have the concept of "I attack, then you can punish me for attacking."

If you attack, then you have to get something for it, or you must lose nothing or very little. I think I talked about that in my nothing article. However, I'm specifically referring to making a real attack, and not a 'nothing' attack that isn't really meant to attack. When you go to attack, you have to put your opponent in danger. If you hit the enemy, then they lose health or some other resource. But the other thing they often lose is time, too!

When you get hit by an attack, you can't do anything for a while. If the enemy's attack ends before your hit stun ends, they can use that time to attack again. If you attack, they will probably beat your attack, unless your attack is invulnerable. In many cases you'll just want to defend in order to wait until they leave themselves open...

If your attack hits or gets blocked, there may be another situation though. If the opponent recovers from getting hit or blocking before you do, they can attack and you are now in the dangerous spot!

In a first-person shooter or similar game, losing a team member is often a form of tempo loss (in CS or other elimination games it's a resource loss, but in respawn games it's time). While that person is waiting to respawn and get into position, your team is weaker until that person can reassert their threat on the battlefield. In games like Gears of War, having a team member who is hurt and needs to be revived is a tempo loss too. If the enemy kills him, he becomes a permanent resource loss. However, in some cases it may be even worse to lose more tempo by reviving your friend who is bleeding out, instead of completing an objective.

I spent a lot of time defining tempo (and time advantage, same thing), but how do we use it?

If we are at time disadvantage, we must know this. If our opponent knows we are at time advantage it is better for him to play safely/defensively (do nothing?!) until they regain the tempo. It might also mean that they do riskier things, like do dragon punches or super moves that are invincible (or parries, etc.)

This means that we have a good idea of what they might do. If we think they will do a dragon punch or other invincible move, we should do nothing and punish them for it. If we think they will do nothing, we should attack and press the advantage in whatever way we can, perhaps by throwing, or by taking objectives that they can't defend with fewer people.

This is of course another reason why you should have as much knowlege about your game as you can, so that you know when you are at advantage.

Protip: if a grenade is at your feet and you have to jump away, you're probably at time disadvantage